Nourish and Nurture
"Nourish and Nurture" is about helping people redefine what it means to be healthy, confident, and strong, embracing a joyful and livable approach to wellness. You’re in the right place if you want that transformation! I’ll be diving into relevant topics, sharing personal stories, fresh ideas, and practical strategies from my own journey. My hope is that these conversations will resonate with you, inspire you, and guide you along your own path to a healthier, happier you, providing insights that encourage and support you along the way.
Nourish and Nurture
When a Chip is Just a Chip
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Episode #57: When a Chip is Just a Chip:
There is so much dogma in the various camps about the right way or wrong way to do Keto, that it is enough to make a person’s head spin — even for someone who has followed Keto for quite some time. I call this DOGMANTICS. This episode will help you sort through all the different viewpoints on how to do Keto and Low Carb so that you can find something that is comfortable for yourself. The episode also takes you along with me for my trip to Italy where I discovered that sometimes a chip is just a chip, and sometimes a gelato is just a gelato.
4:19. Dogmantics
8:13. A Paradigm Shift within a paradigm shift
11:59. When a chip is just a chip
16:10. Boxes and Boundaries
16:58. Pandora's Box
20:50. What kind of boxes should you use?
20:24. Fuzzy Boundaries
26:36. What this has meant to me
28:44. This week's Actionable Coaching Advice
32:15. Coming up next week
Be sure to sign up for the Nourish and Nurture Newsletter at miriamhatoum.com/resources to receive 9 spectacular freebies instantly to your inbox.
Episode #: 57 When a Chip is Just a Chip
You’re Listening to the Keto and Low Carb Success podcast, Episode # 57, When a Chip is Just a Chip.
Did you know that you don't have to spend money on a diet program or weigh, measure and track your food? What if you could learn to have success by following an easy roadmap that takes you on adventures from learning how to change your mindset so that you can believe in yourself, to learning about what foods work best in your body and why? Join me, Miriam Hatoum, health coach, course creator and author of Conquer Cravings with Keto, as I give you actionable coaching advice that is sure to empower you so that you will finally find peace with food and learn to trust your body’s signals. You’ve got this, girl!
Be sure to go to miriamhatoum.com/resources to get all the free guides to help you along the way. I am in your shoes, my friends, and I wrote these guides for both of us. The link is in the show notes and transcripts.
Oh, and before we start, I want to let you know that the primary purpose of this podcast and the course is to educate and does not constitute medical advice or service, and I’m keeping up with the science as fast as I can so I can share with you the latest breaking research in this area to help you achieve your dreams!
==========
Now on to today’s episode:
4:19 Dogmantics:
· Okay, listen up! There is so much dogma in the various camps about the right way or wrong way to do Keto, that it is enough to make a person’s head spin — even for someone who has followed Keto for quite some time.
· Net carbs vs. total carbs.
o Tracking vs. not tracking.
o Moderate protein vs. high protein.
o Plate fat vs. body fat.
o Extended fasting . . . intermittent fasting . . . never fasting. If it fits your macros (IIFYM). Lazy Keto.
o One Meal a Day (OMAD).
o Peanuts, no peanuts.
o Soy, no soy.
o Calories matter vs. calories do not count.
o GNG (gluconeogenesis): immediate horror vs. not-so-fast and negligible.
o Count macros, don’t count macros.
· On and on. All these rules (which are supported in as many varying measures as the people who live by them are varied) add up to a big pile of confusion for newbies and experienced alike, and often are fodder for huge social media drama — including, but not limited to, people being kicked out of Facebook groups! I henceforth declare this drama DOGMANTICS.
· I have worked my way through every piece of that dogma since my beginnings with Keto.
o As a matter of fact, my first stab at social media was "Keto My Way."
o I was so confused that on almost a weekly basis I changed what I was doing (most notably my issues with tracking vs. not tracking, and net carbs vs. total carbs).
o I called it my journey, but actually I was just fumbling around, advancing very little in my understanding of how to do Keto. I lost weight and my health markers improved — just by virtue of the fact that I kept my carbs low, be they net or total.
· When I became a coach, my very first promise to myself was that I would not take part in any of these dogmantics and that I would do my best to help my clients do Keto their way with the knowledge I had and the information I respected.
· But even with that promise to myself and to my clients, I felt more like a wanderer than a confident Granny Keto.
· At the time, I had a very long talk with Amy Berger, the person who wrote the foreword of my book, Conquer Cravings with Keto, and author of The Alzheimer's Antidote and The Stall Slayer.
o She is so incredibly the voice of reason; she helped me sort out many of my questions and concerns, helped me see that my voice in this community can say “STOP THE DOGMANTICS!”
o I also had the right to say NO to some of the dogma out there, i.e., you must fast, you must keep your protein moderate (and how do you even define “moderate”?), you must eat fat — lots of it, and if you are hungry or are stalled then for sure you must eat more fat!
o One of the goals of this podcast, Low Carb and Keto Success, is to help you find your voice and your way among everything out there that sometimes you feel you are slogging through.
8:13 Paradigm shift within the paradigm shift
Ultimately Keto is about keeping your carbs low (and even that can have a range once you get to know your body).
· Keto is so much simpler than the perpetrators of dogmantics would have you believe.
o Keep total carbs below 20 (to start).
o Eat plenty of fresh leafy green and above-ground vegetables that either do not have to be counted in those 20 carbs, or if you must, at least count them as net (no, this is not permission to eat a bathtub full of salad — but neither do you have to measure out a scant two cups and take out the extra three lettuce leaves).
o And as far as protein and fat are concerned, I really depart from the dogmantics of the issues and instead venture into the more reasonable and kind viewpoints.
· Back to my conversation with Amy Berger: I told her that I am hungry all the time and she was aghast when I told her how scaled back my protein was (50–60g daily). She said that 80–100 grams of protein should be the basement level of what I was eating, and that I am probably not losing weight because I am eating too much fat in an attempt to assuage that hunger.
· In most dogmantics camps, if someone says they are hungry or aren't losing weight, the answer always is "EAT MORE FAT."
· For me, however, the extra fat will never stop the hunger, but a bit of tuna will always increase the time I can go between meals!
· I intuitively knew this, but because of the dogmantics between the “plate fat camps” and the "body fat camps," and although I understood that calories don’t count (in the context of 200 calories of butter is better for you than 100 calories of candy), I felt shunned by some groups for leaning towards the view that if you excessively eat plate fat you will never burn body fat.
· By the way, there is a lot of self-shaming going on in social media dogmantics so be careful. Don’t give in or give up if your needs differ.
· This is less so now than it was 4 or 5 years ago, as we are finding out more about needing more protein as you get older because your body processes it less efficiently.
· Again, the success of Keto is keeping carbs low.
· Period.
· I am in a Low Carb cycle right now, but whenever I return to Keto, I moderate fat and eat more protein. This is not permission to eat a 2-pound steak in one sitting! It just means that if I am hungry, maybe I will reach for a chicken leg or a deviled egg instead of a fat bomb or broth with butter.
· On Amy’s advice, I re-read Dr. Atkins' New Diet Revolution and New Atkins for a New You. I also devoured work by Dr. Ted Naiman. Please look him up — he has his own site as well as wonderful articles, graphics and videos on The Diet Doctor site. It is possible for all these voices of reason to knock the dogmantics out of your own head so that you can move forward and find all the success you deserve!
11:59 When a chip is just a chip
This is a good example about going against dogmantics, but in a way that is good for the soul. This experience that I share here is about my family’s trip to Italy.
· Before I had gone, I read a blog post by someone I respect that was about "going off" Keto, and that if you ate a food that you looked forward to (for example, cake at a wedding), then it would be a marker of flat-out food addiction.
· Within context, I understood the point — that if you have been finding health and weight loss and freedom from craving with Keto, why would you take the first step onto what could be a slippery slope?
· What is driving you to eat that food that would supersede the importance of the results of all the hard work you have done to reach the point where you are at the moment you put that cake in your mouth? I get that.
· But sometimes a chip is just a chip.
· In my case, sometimes a gelato is just a gelato.
o When my daughter got married in Tuscany we planned an anniversary trip back six years later.
o One of the most fun things we did was go walking in the evening in Florence and going to a special gelato shop.
o Yes, the important part here is the experience and not the gelato.
o But for six years I was saying: "When we go back to Italy, I am going to get lemon gelato at that special place and sit looking out at the Ponte Vecchio at sunset."
o Having and savoring that gelato is a vital part of that experience.
o It is a piece of the puzzle — if I take out the gelato, the experience won’t be the same.
o But please take this in context: If I had diabetes or epilepsy or was undergoing a cancer treatment that works synergistically with Keto, I would damn well manage the experience without the gelato.
o But this was not the case.
o Nor was it, in any way, an obsessive food addiction.
· I remember when I first started Keto I said to myself: "This is a way of eating, it is not a religion."
· This was going to be a wonderful trip with lots of family going and lots of food flowing.
· I didn’t see myself eating bread or pasta, or anything that is common and I was not going to use the trip as an excuse to binge or pig-out.
· I was, however, going to use it as a valid reason to have that gelato I have been dreaming about for 6 years — and at that, only at the special place by the Ponte Vecchio . . . at sunset.
· You see, sometimes a chip is just a chip and sometimes a gelato is just a gelato.
o Nothing sinister.
o Nothing evil or slippery about it.
o I am not going to be shamed because of my viewpoint on this.
o If I was going to be considered less of a ketoer than the person who wrote that other blog, then so be it.
o If people don’t want my coaching services because I don’t believe in dogmantics, then so be it. And, believe me, I was warned and warned hard!
o I understood rules, and the wisdom behind these rules, I really did.
o But religion and dogma have no place in beautiful Florence . . at the gelato store . . . at sunset on the Ponte Vecchio.
· And by the way, I did have the pasta because we took a wonderful cooking class in Tuscany where we hand-rolled our own pasta. I was not going to say no to that!
16:10 This brings me to Boxes and Boundaries
· I thought about boxes and boundaries before my trip to Italy when I was so worried about having that gelato in Florence. Well, I don’t know if it was worry so much as it was guilt now that I was Granny Keto and all. I did have the gelato in Florence, and I enjoyed every lick and drip of it. And I probably won’t have any again unless I am traveling in Italy again. I was able to set that boundary on the gelato.
· However, opening that box, where I had put all the Dos and Don’ts for myself, turned out to be a dangerous thing. But actually, just in Italy. So I still had my boundaries even though the box was unsealed.
16:58 Pandora’s box
· Okay, so what did opening that box do?
· If I had stayed with the trinket of “gelato in Florence,” I would have been fine, and actually there is no trinket labeled “gelato all the time everywhere” so I am not worried, but there were other trinkets that glittered at me when I opened the box.
· Being a magpie at heart (there is not a belly dancer anywhere in the world who isn’t!), I could not resist the glittering objects.
· These were:
o “Oh, have a little pasta; it was homemade in the cooking class you took.
o Oh, have that little heel of the baguette — just to soak up the oil and balsamic vinegar of the region.
o Oh, finish that pastry or croissant that the grandchildren left behind — they were just baked fresh at this bakery in Montepulciano.
o Oh, keep eating even though you are full; when will you get this food again?”
o These were the relatively harmless little glittering trinkets in the box.
· Then, once that layer of harmless trinkets was gone, I hit the more sinister sparkling things in Pandora’s box.
o I ate when no one was looking.
o I ate chocolates and fruit and breads when no one was looking.
o Those sneaking behaviors that absolutely stopped once I started Keto came to the surface again.
o The overeating behaviors that mostly stopped once I started Keto came to the surface again.
o The cravings came to the surface again.
o Acting on those cravings came to the surface again — not because the sugar awakened them, but because now I was in the land of reaching and eating and sneaking.
· The difference between opening the box for the gelato and digging through the box were entirely different.
o I openly enjoyed the gelato — no shame and no explanation to anyone.
o I finished mine and licked the dripping gelato from the grandchildren.
o I tried everyone’s flavors.
o It was a fun excursion.
· But going deep into the box was not a fun excursion. It frightened me as to where things could go again, realizing that the dark side has not vanished.
· Had I widened the permission from the start, I would have been more at ease with the pasta and bread, pastries and cookies and cake.
o The difference is, I would have enjoyed a sampling — in front of everyone — and been done with it.
o It wasn’t the food that made me feel bad, it was the behavior that surrounded the eating of the food.
· A purist — a dogmantic — would have said that I shouldn’t have opened the box at all and that I should not have strayed off Keto one bit.
· I decided seven months before the trip I was going to have that gelato, so the purist ship had already sailed.
· And, in all honesty, once I got home that box was closed tight — so I still did have boundaries.
· I think that, for me, opening that box was not horrible — I learned some valuable lessons about myself and the situation. It is the behavior around the food that drives my behavior around the food.
20:50 What kind of boxes should you use?
I have beautiful mesh boxes with lids. They are not solid, dark, deep boxes with lids that weigh a ton and have locks on them. I think these dark heavy boxes are the kinds of boxes where we put our forbidden food and forbidden behaviors.
· I believe my gelato was in that type of box, and that is why, once the lid was raised, all the other foods and behaviors glittered and mocked me and dared me to just try one.
· If I had put my gelato in mesh box, I think I would have seen the gelato, reached in, had it and then been done with it instead of being drawn into the dark box to look at everything else.
· Maybe I could have used one of those mesh boxes to hold the pasta and bread; another one pastries, cookies and cake.
· I could have looked straight through in the sunlight and could have made a decision on reality, not on what was glimmering and calling to me.
· I could have opened one, had some bread, but then have seen that there was more and that nothing came from lack, deprivation and secretiveness.
· I might have had nothing from the other boxes because I could see them for what they were, and not glittering secrets and temptations.
· Yes, use boxes, but the right kind!
22:24 And let’s talk about Fuzzy Boundaries
I listened to a great podcast with Kim Howerton. She used a term that really stuck with me: “Fuzzy Boundaries.” I wanted to talk a bit about that also and what it means to me and those times when I am a culprit.
· First off, I am not talking about not having boundaries at all, but I am talking about when what Keto means to ME is all over the road.
· Picture yourself driving down a highway.
o Have you ever been behind someone who is all over their lane?
o They don’t drive off into the shoulder, and they don’t go into another lane or into oncoming traffic - that person’s hand is probably just searching for their coffee cup.
o Annoying, but probably not going to result in an accident.
o Now picture this: You are committed to Keto, and maybe doing 20 total carbs or less, sticking to clean-Keto-approved foods, eating when you are full and stopping when you are hungry.
23:46 With summer upon us, ‘Tis the season for fuzzy boundaries
· Okay, so you are not going to run yourself off into a ditch or into oncoming traffic.
o But what’s that you said about sticking to 20 total carbs?
o Hmm…maybe we can go up a bit just for the summer season, or switch to net carbs for a week.
o But what’s that you said about eating only clean-Keto-approved foods?
o Hmm…there is that “IIFYM” method of Keto: As long as it fits my macros I’ll eat it; a few rum balls instead of salad and other vegetables will work out just fine.
o But what’s that you said that eating when you’re hungry and stopping when you’re full?
o Hmm…as long as I am eating Keto foods, no harm done as long as I am only eating rib-eyes and green salad even if I am stuffed until I am sick and probably consumed about 5000 calories more than my body will ever burn off.
· You get the point: You can still be totally in your lane but swerving all over the place.
o You might get knocked out of ketosis, but the more fat-adapted you are, the more metabolically resilient your body is, the more quickly you get back into ketosis, so you figure you have some leeway.
· And, in truth, remaining in ketosis will still bring good health results, just maybe not the weight loss you want, because eating too much is still eating too much, even if it’s Keto.
· Just as it happens, if you are only reaching for your coffee, you get right back onto the straight and narrow of the road.
· But what if one meal or one day turns into a month, several months or you never do get back onto Keto?
· Yeah, you can run your car off into a ditch, or God forbid, kill other people and yourself.
· But it also makes another point:
o Assuming you are not impaired and you do not take your eyes off the road, you will still probably stray a bit off your mark even if you are doing something so slight like reaching for that coffee.
o And in the same way I am not talking about going back to the Standard American Diet (SAD) of mindlessly eating hundreds, if not thousands, of junk carbohydrates.
o I am talking about the equivalent of reaching for that coffee: a few extra carbs, not stopping when you are full, or looking for ways for foods to fit your macros.
26:36 What this has meant to me and what I am going to do about it
· Guilty as charged! Yeah, you all know my story: the hard and emotional year I had years ago: the complete life-changing events like retirement and house hunting, and the busier-than-ever days in my life just with the production of Granny Keto (all good but busy!).
· It was easy for those boundaries to get fuzzy…very very fuzzy. Never off Keto, but coming dangerously close to driving into a ditch, believe me. I was starting to feel bad that I am barely an example for my clients, but then realized that, as they say, “life happens” and really it’s time to take a few refresher driving classes and keep my eye on the road better than I have been.
· The refresher classes meant getting back to listening to my favorite keto and low carb podcasts which always grounded and focused me, listening more to my body signals to tell me when I am hungry or satisfied, less reaching for a little bit of this and a little bit of that because I know I have been very low in carbs for the day, and a few wasabi peas or grapes won’t hurt.
· Thank heavens I did not drive into a ditch that year, but although I am pleased with that, I was not pleased that I made virtually no progress in attaining my weight loss goals.
· I always say - and I stand by it - that weight loss in Keto is beside the point, but it’s still nice to see you aren’t leaving a year heavier than you went into it - even if only by a few pounds.
· Anyway - stay on that road, unfuzz your boundaries, and get on with your journey and enjoy it!
28:44 Actionable Coaching Advice
You could be listening to this podcast at any time of year, but it is going live the first week of July. I think – even more so than the holidays which are just a sprinkling through the winter months – this time of year is hard for many of us because we might be totally of schedule with work and maybe if you have kids. For me, more than anything, it is the longer days. I know that it is nice for it to be light out at 7PM, and I know it’s the same 24 hours in a day, but the day just seems longer, and with that, it is sometimes harder for me to stay on an eating schedule. Never mind the travel, parties, and summer foods like ice cream and endless fruits.
· This week for your assignment I want you to look at your calendar for the summer – and if that’s too much, look just 2-3 weeks out, and notice where you might be facing other-than-normal eating schedules and foods.
· What do you think might fit well into those mesh boxes?
o Do you want to allow yourself a hotdog and bun and some potato salad at a family BBQ?
o Would you enjoy going out for ice cream cones with the grandkids?
o Are you taking a road trip and would like to loosen the rules around McDonalds or Burger King?
o Are you taking a staycation, and want to have some guidelines for so many meals at home?
· You don’t have to plan these meals in advance, so much as decide what boundaries you are comfortable with.
o Maybe you will have some blueberry pie and ice cream at the family picnic, but that won’t be the week that you also go out for ice cream.
o Maybe you decide you will go to MacDonalds, but not supersize everything.
o Go back and listen to Episode 49 about If-Then protocols and set some up for yourself: If you have potato salad then you will not also have chips. If you have a hot dog roll then you will have a hamburger on the plate without the roll.
· Honestly, just shining a light on some of these things and getting them out of that deep dark Pandora’s box will help you so much, without making dozens of rules this summer.
I also encourage you, as part of your coaching, to take a look at my new course, Keto and Low Carb Success at miriamhatoum.com/course. There is so much in there that will help you find your footing with all of this.
And, let me remind you. If you’ve ever got a question you’d like to ask me or share a topic idea that you would like me to cover on a future episode, don’t be a stranger! I always look forward to hearing from listeners like you. You are welcome to email me directly… miriam@miriamhatoum.com. And don’t forget to leave a review wherever you listen to this podcast. I would SO appreciate it. Leaving a review makes it easier for other people who are looking to listen and learn about Keto and Low Carb.
32:15 Coming up in the next Episode
I have talked some about my Keto Cycles and my Low Carb Cycles. Next week I will talk about a flexible approach to doing Keto and Low Carb. Learning to be flexible has helped me in my journey and I hope it will give you some new insights as well.
Please share this show with your friends and invite them to tune in with you and learn how to become free from diet prison with my Keto and Low Carb Success podcast. Especially share this podcast with anyone you know who is struggling with their weight or eating plan. This podcast and my course can be game changers if you take the information and coaching advice that are in them, they really are. It will help so many people transform their lives – not just with food but with how they feel about themselves, how they approach the food they eat, and how they make decisions about any area of their lives.
Until the next episode, go live free from diet worry — I’ll see you back here next time.
Get all my free guides
Take a look at this great course
Join me on Facebook
Follow me on Instagram
Check out Pinterest
And don't forget my book!